Copyright 2002 The Scotsman Publications Ltd.
Scotland on Sunday
October 27, 2002, Sunday
SECTION:
Pg. 1
LENGTH: 479 words
HEADLINE: CANCER LINK FORCES U-TURN ON
POWER
LINES NEAR HOMES
BYLINE: Jeremy Watson
BODY:
POWER lines
will
have to be built at least 150 metres from homes or even buried to minimise the
health risks to people living nearby, under a new recommendation to the
government.
The National Radiological Protection Board (NRPB) is to
issue the tough new guidelines amid growing evidence of the health risks posed
by high-voltage cables and the electromagnetic fields they produce.
If
the government adopts the new standards, some existing high voltage
power lines will have to be raised to increase the distance
between them and homes below. The NRPB proposals are the first tightening up of
the rules on placing
power lines
for almost a decade and have
reignited the debate over the link between electromagnetic fields and cancer
clusters.
In one group of houses closest to the
power
lines on the Shortlees estate in Kilmarnock, nine people have died of
cancer in the past 15 years.
The safety limit is expected to be
drastically lowered under the NRPB proposals from 1,600 microteslas - the unit
in which electromagnetic fields are measured - to just 100.
Last night,
lawyers said the toughened guidelines could prompt a renewed flood of legal
actions from cancer victims and their families.
Solicitor Martyn Day,
who attempted to take the power companies to court on the issue in the 1990s,
said the lowering of the limit suggested the previous level of 1,600 was not
safe.
"It will certainly lead me to reopen files and reconsider the
strength of these particular actions," he said.
"There are potentially
hundreds of families around who might have a case."
The NRPB
recommendation has been given fresh impetus by evidence from its own medical
advisory committee last year that children living near
power
lines are at double the risk of developing leukaemia.
Research
in both Britain and the US has since produced evidence that women who live near
overhead
power lines are five times more likely to suffer a
miscarriage.
The Electricity Association, which represents power
companies, claims the fields generated by most existing high-voltage lines in
the UK already fall below the 100 microteslas limit so would not have to be
moved.
But Dr John Swanson, the association's scientific adviser, said
there were "scenarios" in which changes would have to be made if the new limit
was set.
Up to 12,000 miles of high-voltage transmission cables
criss-cross Britain with around 3,000 miles in Scotland. They run directly over
or close to around 27,000 homes, and 600,000 people live within 100 metres.
Health campaigners will seize on the NRPB proposal to demand the
eventual burial of all power cables.
But the electricity companies will
resist this because every mile of underground cabling costs nearly GBP 16m to
install, whereas overhead cables cost about 800,000 pounds for the same
distance.
LOAD-DATE: October 30, 2002